www.montereycountynow.com september 5-11, 2024 MONTEREY COUNTY WEEKLY 13 Back in 2015, a grassroots group of Monterey County residents launched a campaign, originating with a desire to ban fracking in Monterey County. It was a preemptive effort, as fracking has never been widely deployed in the San Ardo Oil Field. But when the Monterey County Board of Supervisors declined to implement a moratorium on fracking, it galvanized the group into action—they would take local land-use policy governing oil industry practices into their own hands. The group, called Protect Monterey County, authored a ballot measure that expanded beyond the original vision, and included a prohibition on new wastewater injection wells (a standard operating practice for the oil industry), and a ban on drilling new oil wells. In 2016, Protect Monterey County celebrated a landslide victory with 56 percent of the vote supporting Measure Z. Despite being outspent by the industry by a margin of about 33-to-1, their campaign prevailed. But then came a yearslong slog through the courts. A coalition—led by Chevron and including property owners who hold mineral rights and local school districts—sued, seeking to block implementation of Measure Z. Eventually, after taking their case all the way to the California Supreme Court in 2023, they lost. It was up to state regulators, not local government, to regulate oil and gas, the court ruled. Enter state lawmakers representing the region. Assemblymember Dawn Addis, D-Morro Bay, says the motivation to legislate a solution to this issue came from Monterey County constituents. And the battle, with a heavy presence of oil industry lobbying, repeated in Sacramento. Late on Saturday, Aug. 31, just about 10 minutes before midnight and before the year’s legislative session ended, state lawmakers passed Addis’ Assembly Bill 3233, which “would authorize a local entity, as defined, by ordinance, to limit or prohibit oil and gas operations or development in its jurisdiction.” In essence, the law enables local initiatives or ordinances like Measure Z, handing decision-making authority to local government. AB 3233 passed 46-15 off the Assembly floor, and 21-12 off the Senate floor. It’s an interesting moment when it comes to local versus state decisions about land use. There’s been lots of hand-wringing about housing goals set forth by the state, which is directing local jurisdictions to deliver on new units. I asked Addis what makes this different—isn’t it useful for the state to have consistent oversight? “This is not a controversial issue unless you’re in the oil and gas industry,” she says. “You have nurses, teachers, counties, an environmental coalition—a broad group of supporters—say, ‘We want to uplift the health and welfare of our communities.’ It was a surprise to many when Measure Z was overturned, and a dangerous precedent to overturn the will of the voters.” Since she was elected in 2022, Addis created a Central Coast Caucus, bringing together the 10 state senators and assemblymembers who represent five counties: Monterey, Santa Cruz, San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara and Ventura. All 10 supported AB 3233. “When I got elected, one of my main goals was to make sure the Central Coast really had a voice in the Legislature,” Addis says. The bill isn’t law yet; it is still awaiting Gov. Gavin Newsom’s signature or veto. Even if it is chaptered into law, it may not yet be out of the woods on litigation. The opposition argument from the Western States Petroleum Association states, “By allowing local governments to adopt ordinances that may prohibit or significantly restrict an operator’s right to operate its existing oil and gas production wells or other facilities, AB 3233 has the potential to expose these local governments to significant liability. Operators hold valuable property rights in their existing operations.” If the bill does become law— and I hope it does—California’s oil-producing future will likely be a patchwork. Some counties will implement stronger restrictions; others will codify the right of industry to operate. What we do know is the landscape of the country’s third-largest oil- and gas-producing state, with over 242,000 wells, will look different. And it will be thanks to a group of local Monterey County residents. Sara Rubin is the Weekly’s editor. Reach her at sara@montereycountynow.com. Oiled Up Assemblymember Dawn Addis scores a big victory against Big Oil. By Sara Rubin Let Them Eat Cake…Squid recently came across a press release from the Soledad Community Health Care District labeled “Exciting News.” The “news” was that SCHCD CEO Ida Chan had been nominated for “CEO of the Year,” for the Association of California Healthcare Districts. It turns out nominations can come from an executive colleague or board member, which made the news less exciting and dubious at best. The press release said in her four years as CEO she had transformed the district into “a beacon of hope and progress.” For a district that is running at a deficit and where employees regularly complain about pay and work conditions, this seemed extremely dubious. On Aug. 30, SEIU 2015 announced that a majority of SCHCD workers voted to form a union. According to union leaders, workers want to bring attention to “unsustainable turnover,” low staffing levels and burned-out workers. They plan on negotiating for a “liveable wage, adequate health coverage, safe staffing and freedom from fear and repercussions.” On Aug. 27, Chan declared to her employees she won CEO of the Year, and everyone got cake. The kicker is that it’s possible her announcement was premature—the ACHD posted information about voting online before the final tally was tabulated. The winner will be announced on Sept. 25. Squid will be standing by, with cake, awaiting the result. Vote Count…Squid has been watching as the Democratic Party coalesces around the presidential race, but Squid usually doesn’t ooze too far from the lair, and prefers to keep Squid’s eyes on the Monterey County Democratic Central Committee. It’s endorsement season—“the most important work we do,” Chair Karen Araujo told members on Aug. 27, when they convened to make endorsements for the Nov. 5 election—so Squid is listening in. Endorsements are a matter of math (it takes 60 percent of voting members to get the party’s blessing), and first came a debate about the number of voting members, which requires them to be in good standing. State Sen. John Laird was paid up, but his alternate, Sean Edwards, who was appointed to represent Laird in case of an absence, was not—Edwards is completing a partial term vacated by former alternate Pris Walton, who had paid through the year. Advocating not to let Edwards vote was Alan Haffa: “We are a democracy, not an oligarchy,” he said. “Elected officials at the state level are no more important than other members of this body.” Others advocated to allow Edwards to vote on Laird’s behalf: “We are the party of allowing people the right to vote,” said Cristina Medina Dirksen. The dues rule was eventually overridden, but it didn’t matter anyway—almost every endorsement vote was a landslide, anyway. the local spin SQUID FRY THE MISSION OF MONTEREY COUNTY WEEKLY IS TO INSPIRE INDEPENDENT THINKING AND CONSCIOUS ACTION, ETC. “We want to uplift the health of our communities.” Send Squid a tip: squid@montereycountynow.com
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjAzNjQ1NQ==